When facing the aftermath of a criminal conviction, the emotional toll can feel overwhelming, especially when the verdict does not seem just. In Texas, the appeals process is a legal right that allows individuals to challenge their convictions if they believe errors were made during the trial. These errors can range from procedural mistakes to improper rulings or misinterpretations of the law. Understanding how the appeals process works and what options are available is crucial in seeking justice and possibly overturning a conviction. This page aims to explain the process of appealing a criminal conviction in Texas, outlining the steps involved, the grounds for appeal, and the importance of timely action.
What Is an Appeal?
An appeal is not a retrial. It is important to understand that an appellate court does not reexamine the facts of the case or the evidence presented during the trial. Instead, the appellate court reviews the procedures and decisions made by the trial court to determine if any legal errors occurred that could have affected the outcome. The goal is to ensure that the trial was conducted fairly, that the defendant’s rights were upheld, and that the law was correctly applied.
In Texas, the process of appealing a criminal conviction begins with filing a notice of appeal. This must be done within a strict time frame, usually within 30 days of the conviction or sentencing. Missing this deadline can result in losing the right to appeal, which is why it is vital to act promptly after a conviction.
Grounds for Appealing a Conviction
Appealing a conviction is only possible if there are legitimate grounds to do so. It is not enough to simply disagree with the outcome of the trial. Instead, the appeal must be based on specific legal errors that occurred during the trial. These errors could involve improper instructions given to the jury, evidence that was wrongly admitted or excluded, prosecutorial misconduct, ineffective assistance of counsel, or violations of the defendant’s constitutional rights.
Robert L. Rush
Founding Partner
Kurt W. Gransee
Founding Partner
One common ground for appeal is the argument that the trial court made incorrect rulings on matters of law. For example, if the judge allowed inadmissible evidence to be presented to the jury, this could form the basis of an appeal. Similarly, if the judge gave improper instructions to the jury, this could be seen as an error that warrants an appellate review.
Another ground for appeal could be ineffective assistance of counsel. Every defendant is entitled to competent legal representation, and if it can be demonstrated that the defense attorney failed to provide adequate representation, this could lead to a successful appeal. Examples of ineffective assistance include failing to investigate key evidence, not calling crucial witnesses, or making poor strategic decisions during the trial.
The Appeals Process
The process of appealing a criminal conviction in Texas begins with filing a notice of appeal in the trial court. This notice alerts the court and the prosecution that the defendant intends to appeal the conviction. Once the notice is filed, the appellant (the individual appealing the conviction) must submit a written brief to the appellate court. This brief outlines the legal arguments and the reasons why the conviction should be overturned.
I would like to thank Mr kurt Gransee, from day one he was very knowledgeable about the laws regarding my case and was very confident of getting a dismiss. He managed my case professionally and we got the dismiss in less than 2 months! If Mr Gransee take your case, he will be confident of what he is able to do. Thank you again Mr Gransee”
- Ali Alkufaishi
I had a 10 year probation on a felony charge. I got in trouble and they already had a Motion to Revoke Probation. I was worried cause my original lawyer had just died. I prayed and searched on the internet for a lawyer. Kurt Gransee was the name I stopped at. I called him and he was able to hear my plea. He set me up on a payment plan and went to work on my case. He developed a strategic defense and was able to dismiss the MTR. I was finally a free man!!! So, if you are looking for a lawyer that will work hard for you and has your best interest at heart, you definitely need Kurt Gransee in your corner. He is the best. His firm is professional & his secretary, Elsa, always kept me and my family well informed."
- Damien Gomez
I could not be more satisfied with the work Mr. Gransee did for me. He went above and beyond to get me the best deal I possibly could and it exceeded all my expectations. He was communicative, friendly, and incredibly helpful when I was dealing with an experience that I never thought I would be in. He put my mind at ease right from our initial conversation. I would recommend him to anyone who is in a dubious and uncertain position. Top notch professionalism, all day."
- Banner Matney
The prosecution also has the opportunity to submit a brief defending the conviction and arguing that the trial court’s decisions were correct. In some cases, the appellate court may schedule oral arguments, during which both sides present their case to a panel of judges. However, not all appeals require oral arguments, as many are decided based solely on the written briefs.
After reviewing the briefs and hearing any oral arguments, the appellate court will issue a ruling. The court can either affirm the conviction, reverse the conviction, or send the case back to the trial court for further proceedings. If the appellate court finds that a significant error occurred during the trial, it may reverse the conviction and order a new trial or, in some cases, dismiss the charges altogether.
What Happens If an Appeal Is Denied?
If an appeal is denied, it does not necessarily mean that the fight is over. In some cases, it may be possible to file a motion for rehearing, asking the appellate court to reconsider its decision. Alternatively, the appellant may choose to petition a higher court, such as the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals or even the United States Supreme Court, to review the case. However, higher courts typically only hear a small percentage of cases, and the standards for review are often stricter.
Additionally, if an appeal is unsuccessful, there may still be other legal avenues available, such as filing for post-conviction relief. This can include a writ of habeas corpus, which challenges the legality of the defendant’s detention based on new evidence, constitutional violations, or other issues that were not addressed in the original trial or appeal.
Related Videos
Choosing a Criminal Defense Attorney
Bailing Someone Out of Jail
The Importance of Working with a Skilled Legal Team
Navigating the appeals process requires a deep understanding of both Texas law and appellate procedure. It is a complex process that involves meticulous research, thorough legal analysis, and compelling arguments. For these reasons, working with a knowledgeable legal team can significantly increase the chances of a successful appeal.
Unlike trial courts, where much of the focus is on presenting evidence and witness testimony, appellate courts focus solely on legal arguments. Therefore, an attorney handling an appeal must have the ability to analyze the trial record, identify potential errors, and craft persuasive legal arguments that can stand up to scrutiny.
It is important to note that appellate work is different from trial work. A trial attorney may excel in cross-examining witnesses and delivering compelling opening statements, but appellate work demands a different skill set. It requires the ability to think strategically about legal issues, understand complex procedural rules, and effectively communicate those arguments in writing.
Timeliness and Deadlines in the Appeals Process
Time is of the essence when appealing a criminal conviction. Texas law imposes strict deadlines on when an appeal can be filed, and missing these deadlines can mean forfeiting the right to appeal altogether. In most cases, the notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days of the conviction or sentencing. This is a short window, and it underscores the importance of acting quickly after a conviction.
Once the notice of appeal is filed, the appellant and their legal team will need to prepare a written brief outlining the legal errors made during the trial. This brief is the cornerstone of the appeal, and it requires a comprehensive review of the trial record to identify any mistakes that could have affected the outcome of the case.
Because of the strict deadlines and the complexity of the appellate process, it is critical to consult with an experienced legal team as soon as possible after a conviction. A delay in taking action could result in losing the opportunity to challenge the conviction, even if significant legal errors were made during the trial.
The Role of the Appellate Court
The appellate court’s role is not to determine guilt or innocence but to review the trial court’s decisions to ensure that the law was applied correctly. The court looks for errors that may have influenced the jury’s verdict or affected the fairness of the trial. If the appellate court finds that an error was significant enough to impact the outcome, it may overturn the conviction or order a new trial.
However, not all errors will result in a reversal. The appellate court will only overturn a conviction if the error was considered “harmful” and had a substantial effect on the verdict. Minor errors, known as “harmless errors,” may not be sufficient to justify overturning the conviction. This is why the written brief must be well-researched and persuasive, highlighting how the errors in question affected the fairness of the trial.
Appealing a criminal conviction in Texas is a complicated process that requires careful legal analysis and a strong understanding of appellate law. It is not about retrying the case but about ensuring that legal errors made during the trial are corrected. Time is a critical factor, and acting quickly after a conviction is essential to preserving the right to appeal. Working with a legal team experienced in appellate law can make all the difference in seeking justice.
If you or a loved one is considering appealing a criminal conviction, time is of the essence. Reach out to Rush & Gransee, L.C. today to discuss your options. Our team is dedicated to providing the guidance and support you need during this challenging time. Contact us for a consultation and take the first step toward seeking justice.
